This entry should be considered as unproven. Searches for Eliza Kidney/Carnagie/Carnegie have so far failed to find any valid source. The only source quoted for her in the available family trees is "Gravestone in Pembroke Cemetery". However, specific searches in cemeteries named Pembroke on the Find a Grave and BillionGraves websites return no match for an Eliza or Elizabeth Kidney, Carnagie or Carnegie who was born in 1807, died in 1883, or was married to Ira Barnum. A broader search for those names and dates worldwide has also failed to find a valid, verifiable source.